The Power of Placebo: What Happens When You Believe You’re Taking Steroids.
15 athletes were scattered around the room. Everyone was looking at Gideon Ariel.
“We’re going to give you steroids,” he lied.
It was 1972, and Ariel was conducting a study on athletic performance with his research partner William Saville. On this particular day, the two men were offering the athletes an interesting proposition.
Ariel explained that the study would last for 11 weeks. The athletes would lift weights for the first seven weeks, and those who made the most improvement during that period would be rewarded with Dianabol, an anabolic steroid, for the final four weeks of training.
What the athletes didn’t know was that the researchers were lying to them. After the initial seven-week training period, the scientists randomly selected six athletes as the winners. However, despite being told they were getting real steroids, the athletes actually received placebo pills.
What happened next surprised everyone.
Four weeks later, when the researchers conducted the final test, the athletes set all-time personal records in every exercise tested. Before the placebo pills, the lifters added an average of 5.8 lbs (2.6 kg) to their squat during the first seven weeks of training. After they believed they were taking steroids, they added an average of 41.8 lbs (18.9 kg) in just four more weeks of training.
That’s a 7x increase in nearly half the time. (1)
The same scene played out in nearly every exercise. During the first seven weeks of training, the lifters increased their bench press by about 10 lbs (4.5 kg) on average. After four weeks of receiving placebo pills that they believed to be steroids, the athletes added an average of 29.3 lbs (13.3 kg) to their bench press numbers.
On military press, they increased by an average of 1.6 lbs (0.7 kg) during the initial seven-week period, but added an average of 16.7 lbs (7.6 kg) during the four weeks on placebo pills. (2)
The evidence was clear. Every athlete got stronger simply because they believed they were on steroids. They expected to improve and so they did. (3)
The Placebo Effect
The placebo effect (or placebo response) occurs when a fake treatment improves a person’s condition simply because the person has the expectation that it will be helpful.
For example, imagine a hypothetical weight loss study that divides participants into two groups.
- Group A is told they are taking a weight loss pill, but actually receives a sugar pill as a placebo.
- Group B is told they are taking a weight loss pill and actually receives one.
If Group A loses weight, then they are said to have experienced the placebo effect (they lost weight simply because they expected to lose weight). If Group B loses the same amount of weight as Group A, then the weight loss pill is deemed ineffective because it didn’t work any better than the placebo.
The placebo effect often gets a negative connotation because if a new drug doesn’t work better than a placebo, then it doesn’t work. So, we tend to associate the placebo effect with things that don’t work. This mindset can be useful for testing new drugs, but it tends to hide an important message:
Placebo improvements are still real improvements. Those weren’t real steroids the athletes were given, but those were real gains that they made in the gym. Whether they lifted bigger weights because they actually took steroids or because they merely believed they took steroids, either way they lifted bigger weights.
If you believe something works, then it probably works. But not always for the reasons you thought.
If You Think It Works, It Works
When we believe a particular strategy works, we find ways to make it work. The power of the placebo effect — and, more generally, having the expectation of success — is that it pulls your mind into a focused state where you actively seek out all of the reasons you will succeed.
We all have a default level of performance. Most of our days are spent grinding away at an average speed. But I am convinced that there is more inside of us — not just a little bit more, but much, much more.
Imagine the results you can enjoy if you can just get your body, your mind, and your heart all rowing in the same direction. Imagine what kind of performance is waiting inside of you, if you can just find the courage and conviction to believe in it.
How can we make ourselves feel this way? How can we convince ourselves to believe that we are capable of more?
Honestly, I’m not sure. Properly balancing your psychology and your performance is a tricky thing to do. However, the placebo effect makes one thing very clear: you have untapped potential inside of you, and it is just waiting to come out.
This article was originally published on JamesClear.com.
- Every athlete in the study had been lifting weights for at least two years, and they were fairly strong already. Before the experiment, each athlete could bench press around 295 lbs (133 kg), squat about 300 lbs (135 kg), and military press almost 195 lbs (88 kg). In other words, they weren’t beginners.
- “Anabolic Steroids: The Physiological Effects of Placebos” by G. Ariel and W. Saville. Medicine and Science in Sports (1972). p.124-126
- The performance increases published in the study by Ariel and Saville are larger than usual. That said, the impact of the placebo effect on athletic performance has been proven in a multiple followup studies. This meta-analysis published in the European Journal of Mental Health in 2011 summarizes the current scientific consensus on the topic: “The main finding of this meta-analysis was that placebo treatments have a small to moderate effect on sports performance.”